Ed's Blog

House to vote on rollback of privacy notice rights

By Ed Mierzwinski
Consumer Program Director

On Tuesday, under suspension of the rules, the House may have a vote to roll back some of the privacy notices required as a condition of the 1999 repeal of the Glass-Steagall Act that allowed virtually unfettered sharing of consumer information by and between financial firms, their affiliates and third parties. Reps. Ed Markey (D-MA) and Joe Barton (R-TX), co-chairs of the Bipartisan Congressional Privacy Caucus, marched down the floor today to demand a recorded vote. Here is a youtube video of part of Mr. Markey's empassioned defense. Under suspension of the rules, an expedited procedure, a bill needs 2/3rds (not 50% +1) to pass and is non-amendable. Unless a member does what Reps. Markey and Barton did today, and demands a vote, the suspension calendar bill list passes en bloc without debate. It is usually used for naming post offices, not bills that should have debate.

In 1999, Markey and Barton had passed actual privacy rights legislation through the House Energy and Commerce Committee as part of Congressional consideration of legislation now known as the Gramm-Leach Bliley Financial Modernization Act (GLBA), which tore down the wall between commercial and investment banking. They argued that if commercial banks, investment banks, insurance companies and other firms were all going to be under the same roof, that consumers needed privacy protection. House leaders, in thrall of the big Wall Street banks, used the then-House Banking (now Financial Services) Committee's weak version of the bill instead. As a sop to privacy groups, they threw in a modest privacy opt-out that applies only in very limited circumstances. Under federal law, most sharing cannot be stopped. As a sop, House leaders agreed to require annual privacy notices. But during all this, they refused to allow Markey and Barton a floor vote on their strong privacy rights proposal because Wall Street wanted their preferred bill to pass, not a fair bill to pass. The Markey-Barton amendment would have prevailed on the floor, so they weren't even allowed to get a vote.

So, we ended up with much more limited privacy notices instead of stronger private protections. While consumers, under GLBA, only have a limited right to optout of the sharing of information and then only in some circumstances, its annual privacy notices serve an important educational purpose. HR 5817, the so-called Eliminate Privacy Notice Confusion Act would eliminate annual notices for certain firms, if they haven't changed their sharing practices.

A better way to go would be to have held a hearing with privacy experts as witnesses and then a committee vote. A better way to go would be to require banks to disclose to consumers what privacy preferences they have previously selected so they can consider whether to change them. A better way to go would be to enact Rep. Jackie Speier's (D-CA) bill, HR 653, the Financial Information Privacy Act of 2011, which strengthens the modest privacy protections that will remain in Gramm-Leach-Bliley, even if HR 5817 weakening its privacy notice requirements, is approved. A large part of Rep. Speier's bill is law already in California, where she passed it as a state Senator. Why hasn't industry agreed to pass her bill on suspension? It is already the law for 20% of the population. Taking away privacy education, even limited privacy education, is the wrong way to go.

Comments

MILTON, Ga. {-|--|:|*|( space )|( blank )|,|To|. . .|And|As} ({AP|Elp}) -- {Thomas|Jones|Johnson} Pieters {of|associated with|regarding|involving|connected with|with|for|from|in|about|involved with} {Illinois|The state of illinois|Il} {beat|defeat|conquer|overcome|overcom|whip|do better than|combat|surpass|exhausted|defeated} {Max|Maximum|Utmost|Greatest extent|Optimum|Potential|Chunk|Fatmus|Sloth|Spot|Spork} Homa {with a|having a|using a|which has a|that has a|by using a|which includes a|along with a|by having a|accompanied by a|having} {par|componen|elemen|level|an elemen|a par|snuff|avec} {on the|around the|about the|for the|within the|to the|over the|in the|at the|relating to the|on your} {20th|Twentieth|The twentieth|20 th|Last|20} {hole|pit|gap|opening|ditch|golf hole|problem|pin|target|situation|abyss} {to give|to provide|to offer|to present|to supply|to grant|to allow|to make|giving|to convey|which gives} {Illinois|The state of illinois|Il} {a|the|any|a new|some sort of|your|a good|an important|a fabulous|some|a real} 3-2 {victory|triumph|success|win|glory|wining} {over|more than|above|around|in excess of|through|about|throughout|finished|across|during} top-seeded {California|Ca|Los angeles|Florida|Colorado|Ohio|Ca .|Carolina|Idaho|Arizona|Georgia} {on|upon|about|in|with|for|regarding|concerning|at|relating to|on the subject of} {Saturday|Sunday|Weekend|Wednesday|Thursday|Sat|Friday|Monday|Tuesday|The weekend|This weekend} {in the|within the|inside the|inside|from the|while in the|during the|with the|on the|in your|through the} NCAA {golf|golfing|playing golf|the game of golf|tennis|the sport of golf|golf game|actively playing golf|play golf|world of golf|the game} semifinals. The 15th-seeded Illini {will|may|will certainly|can|will probably|is going to|could|definitely will|might|should|are going to} {face|encounter|deal with|confront|experience|facial area|facial skin|skin|have to deal with|struggle with|are up against} {No|Absolutely no|Simply no|Zero|Virtually no|Not any|Hardly any|Very little|Certainly no|Basically no|Little}. {2|Two|A couple of|Only two|3|A pair of|Couple of|Three|A couple|Step 2|Some} {Alabama|The state of alabama|Birmingham, al|Al|Creola|Chickasaw|Florida|Tennessee} {in the|within the|inside the|inside|from the|while in the|during the|with the|on the|in your|through the} {final|last|ultimate|closing|very last|remaining|previous|finalized|end|finished|overall} {Sunday|Weekend|Saturday|On the|Wednesday|Thursday|Tuesday|Friday|Monday|Sat|Sun}, {with|along with|together with|using|having|by using|utilizing|through|with the help of|by means of|by way of} {both|each|equally|the two|both equally|either|together|each of those|simultaneously|both of those|both the} {seeking|looking for|searching for|in search of|trying to find|trying to get|attempting to get|seeking out|wanting|searching|looking} {their|their own|their particular|his or her|the|its|their very own|ones own|his or her's|his / her|your} firs #file_links\keywords13.txt,1,S] {t|capital t|big t|to|testosterone levels|testosterone|l|w not|longer|g|r} {title|name|identify|subject|headline|concept|brand|label|heading|distinction|term}. {The|The actual|The particular|Your|This|A|Any|Typically the|All the|That|All of the} {Crimson|Pink|Violet|Red|Magenta|Green|Yellow|Blue|Purple colours|Black|A purple pallette} {Tide|Wave|Hold} {beat|defeat|conquer|overcome|overcom|whip|do better than|combat|surpass|exhausted|defeated} {host|web host|sponsor|number|variety|coordinator|hold|coordinate|a lot|throw|multitude} Geo #file_links\keywords11.txt,1,S] rgia {Tech|Technology|Technical|Technological|Computer|Technician|Techie|Support|Mechanic|Specialist|Engineering} 3-0-2 {on the|around the|about the|for the|within the|to the|over the|in the|at the|relating to the|on your} #file_links\keywords14.txt, #file_links\keywords12.txt,1,S] 1,S] {Capital City|Capital} {Club's|Golf club's} Crabapple {Course|Program|Training course|Study course|Training|System|Class|Lessons|Path|Tutorials|School}. "We {won|received|earned|gained|picked up|acquired|triumphed in|claimed|achieved|collected|landed} {five|5|several|a few|all 5|your five|5 various|all five|six|four|some} {tournaments|competitions|events|tourneys|competitive events|matches} {this year|this season|this coming year|in 2010|this current year|this holiday season|at the moment|2010|the year 2010|this present year|the year of 2010},{"|Inch|Inches|In .|In|"|Half inch|Centimeter||Ins|Within} {said|stated|mentioned|explained|claimed|reported|proclaimed|says|suggested|pointed out|talked about} {Illinois|The state of illinois|Il} {coach|trainer|mentor|instructor|private coach|guru|teacher|train|advisor|fitness instructor|tutor} {Mike|Paul|Robert|Henry|Scott|Chris|John|Dave|Simon|Trent|Microphone} {Small|Little|Tiny|Modest|Smaller|Compact|Minor|Small-scale|Minimal|Smallish|Very small}, {whose|in whose|whoever|as their|who is|where|which|where the|exactly where} #file_links\keywords15.txt,1,S] {team|group|staff|crew|workforce|company|squad|organization|power team|party|club} {beat|defeat|conquer|overcome|overcom|whip|do better than|combat|surpass|exhausted|defeated} {defending|protecting|guarding|shielding|safeguarding|counselling|assisting|couseling for|preserving} {champion|champ|winner|success|safe bet|successful|victorious one|victor|king|receiver|champ c3300k} {Texas|Tx|Arizona|Colorado|Florida|Colorado front range|The state of texas|Mississippi|Nevada|New york|New jersey} {on|upon|about|in|with|for|regarding|concerning|at|relating to|on the subject of} {Friday|Fri|Comes to an end|Feb 5th|Exclusive|Saturday|Ending friday|Wednesday|Thursday|Tuesday|Monday} {in the|within the|inside the|inside|from the|while in the|during the|with the|on the|in your|through the} quarterfinals. "People {think|believe|feel|consider|assume|imagine|believe that|suppose|presume|think that|contemplate} {we're|we are|we have been|we've been|were|i am|we live|we're also|we could|our company is|we will} {a|the|any|a new|some sort of|your|a good|an important|a fabulous|some|a real} Cinderella {thing|factor|point|issue|matter|element|idea|item|detail|problem|aspect}. {We're|We are|We have been|We've been|Were|I am|We live|We're also|We could|Our company is|We will} {better than|much better than|a lot better than|superior to|greater than|as good as|quite as good as|far better than|more advanced than|as cool as|compatible with} {people|individuals|folks|men and women|persons|people today|consumers|many people|most people|families|customers} {think|believe|feel|consider|assume|imagine|believe that|suppose|presume|think that|contemplate} {we are|we're|we have been|were|we're also|i am|we've been|our company is|we are now|people are|everyone is}.{"|Inch|Inches|In .|In|"|Half inch|Centimeter||Ins|Within} {Want|Would like|Need|Desire|Wish|Really want|Prefer|Choose|Require|Intend|Like} {sports|sports activities|sporting activities|athletics|activities|sporting events|physical activities|sporting|competitive sports|sports entertainment|professional sports} {news|information|media|reports|announcement|news flash|headlines|press|current information|news reports|thing} {delivered to|sent to|brought to|shipped to|transported to|taken to|provided for|deliver to|transferred to|exposed to|fed to} {your|your own|the|your current|ones|a person's|an individual's|ones own|your personal|any|a} {inbox|mailbox|email|email address|mail} {each morning|every morning|every day|each day|in the morning|each and every morning|the next day|in the am|early in the day|each and every|every}?{Sign up for|Subscribe to|Join|Enroll in|Sign up to|Become a member of|Register for|Be a part of|Check out|Register online for|Get} {our|the|our own|each of our|your|all of our|some of our|much of our|this|a lot of our|many of our} {sports|sports activities|sporting activities|athletics|activities|sporting events|physical activities|sporting|competitive sports|sports entertainment|professional sports} {newsletter|e-newsletter|publication|e-zine|news letter|ezine|bulletin|information sheet|newssheet|e-mag|magazine}

I know your expertise on this. I must say we should have an online discussion on this. Writing only comments will close the discussion straight away! And will restrict the benefits from this information.
http://fb.me/2I8E9Uu9h
http://fb.me/1z6FGBNTX
http://redir.ec/mobilsedancorolla
http://goo.gl/xqhLHF
http://fb.me/32LE7izdi
http://vo.to/ciptojunaedy
http://vo.to/mobilsedancorolla

I know your expertise on this. I must say we should have an online discussion on this. Writing only comments will close the discussion straight away! And will restrict the benefits from this information. I know your expertise on this. I must say we should have an online discussion on this. Writing only comments will close the discussion straight away! And will restrict the benefits from this information.

Are you trying to buy a car? Are you open to the idea of making car shopping more productive, and even fun? This article will provide you with great advice that will help to make your purchase easy and enjoyable. chrusciel-transport.com

There is no better time to start. There are plenty of things you might be curious about before beginning. The following tips will assist you as you get started in the lucrative field of web marketing. bbs-businessschool.com

This is just the information I am finding everywhere.Me and my friend were arguing about an issue similar to this! Now I know that I was right.Thanks for the information you post.

baca selengkapnya
baca selengkapnya
baca selengkapnya

You have done a great job. I will definitely dig it and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site.
muay thai new of 2014-03-16

Once I thought about things like: why such information is for free here? Because when you write a book then at least on selling a book you get a percentage. Thank you and good luck on informing people more about it!
http://bestmattressforlowerbackpain.jimdo.com/

It was great to see the old printshop and everyone who works there again. I am excited to see a printing business still operating and growing, great job guys
http://consumerreportsrevealstopmattres.webnode.com/

It was great to see the old printshop and everyone who works there again. I am excited to see a printing business still operating and growing, great job guys
http://ismemoryfoamsafe.isteaching.com/

Hmm… I read blogs on a similar topic, but i never visited your blog. I added it to favorites and i’ll be your constant reader. Acne

Priority Action

Tell your elected officials: Please protect my right to know, and support GMO labeling.

Support Us

Your donation supports U.S. PIRG’s work to stand up for consumers on the issues that matter, especially when powerful interests are blocking progress.

Consumer Alerts

Join our network and stay up to date on our campaigns, get important consumer updates and take action on critical issues.