Ed's Blog

Should Facebook And Google Be Regulated As Credit Bureaus?

By Ed Mierzwinski
Consumer Program Director

In a series of joint privacy petitions to the Federal Trade Commission beginning in 2006 and extended more recently to include behavioral targeting, as well as medical and mobile marketing, U.S. PIRG and the Center for Digital Democracy (sometimes with allies) have argued for greater scrutiny and regulation of the online digital marketing and behavioral targeting ecosystem that involves not only companies you do business with, but social networking sites you visit, third-party advertisers you never heard of and other players. Today, in the New York Times, Professor Lori Andrews says that "Facebook is Using You."

She asks some questions similar to the ones we've been asking. In particular, should companies that collect and use social networking data to make decisions about you on the Internet have the same responsibilities as credit bureaus, which are companies that collect and sell data for credit, insurance and employment purposes, act as powerful gatekeepers to financial success and are (intended to be at least) strictly regulated in their activities because of what they do and its effect on your opportunities?

As Professor Andrews points out in her column: "Even though laws allow people to challenge false information in credit reports, there are no laws that require data aggregators to reveal what they know about you. If I’ve Googled “diabetes” for a friend or “date rape drugs” for a mystery I’m writing, data aggregators assume those searches reflect my own health and proclivities. Because no laws regulate what types of data these aggregators can collect, they make their own rules."

One encouraging event occurred last May. The FTC warned one company, Social Intelligence Corporation, that "The reports sold by Social Intelligence include public information gathered from social networking sites. Our investigation aimed to determine the company's compliance with the Fair Credit Reporting Act ("FCRA"). Social Intelligence is a consumer reporting agency [credit bureau] because it assembles or evaluates consumer report information that is furnished to third parties that use such information as a factor in establishing a consumer's eligibility for employment. Consumer reporting agencies must comply with several different FCRA provisions, and these compliance obligations apply equally in the social networking context."

Of course, this firm is neither a Facebook nor Google in importance or political power. Further, its activities placed it squarely within the credit reporting laws because its collection and sale of data were for an enumerated purpose under the law, employment decisions. But it is certainly not far-fetched to argue that information collected and sold or shared by the web giants is increasingly being used to make decisions about the opportunities and choices available to consumers. Professor Andrews points out that some consumers could be redlined or denied opportunities based on their search patterns:

"You might be refused health insurance based on a Google search you did about a medical condition. You might be shown a credit card with a lower credit limit, not because of your credit history, but because of your race, sex or ZIP code or the types of Web sites you visit. Data aggregation has social implications as well. When young people in poor neighborhoods are bombarded with advertisements for trade schools, will they be more likely than others their age to forgo college? "

And over at the University of Pennsylvania, Professor Joseph Turow has argued against the use of secret profiles in web data to charge different consumers different prices for the same product (dynamic or differential pricing) and that the unregulated web ecosystem encourages "social discrimination."

The Social Intelligence ruling is just a staff letter, but it is the FTC's enforcement position. Holding web firms and other data brokers accountable as credit bureaus may be the best solution to growing uses of web information for purposes that seem a lot like the credit bureaus-- powerful gatekeepers -- when you look at them and what they do hard enough.

Of course, none of this means that current regulation of the credit bureaus is good enough. Their sloppy practices and arrogant disregard for consumer disputes also need to be addressed. Under the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, as soon as the new Consumer Financial Protection Bureau completes a "larger participants" rulemaking, it will gain new tools that the FTC has never had to look "inside the mysterious black box" that defined the credit reporting system for too long. Larger participant rule comments of the National Consumer Law Center, U.S. PIRG and other leading groups discuss this in detail (49 page pdf, discussion of credit bureaus begins around page 14).

Comments

doudounecanadagoosefrance.fr 92148 Doudoune Canada Goose 49135 canadagoosejacketsaleonline.com
woolrich artic parka 62631 canadagoosejacketsaleonline.com 38363 2012woolricharticparka.com
Canada Goose Parka 99166 2012newcanadagooseoutlet.com 17786 Canada Goose sale
Canada Goose Jacket 36217 giubbotti woolrich 89832 Canada Goose sale
woolrich parka 82735 Canada Goose 68472 Canada Goose Outlet

The iPhone’s Safari browser allow you to do almost anything you can do over a full-sized personal computer, including take images off the Internet. Inside Safari, just feel and hold on tight a photograph you’d want to save.
http://www.tutorial4designer.com

Hey There I found your blog using yahoo. This is a very well written article. I’ll make sure to bookmark it and come back to read more of your useful information. Thanks for the topic I’ll definitely return.

The other actual information http://arentin.blogspot.com/2014/02/unit-link-terbaik-di-indonesia-commo... Unit link terbaik di Indonesia Commonwealth Life investra link , and don't forget check important post http://arentin.blogspot.com Commonwealth Life and best post http://www.postingku.com Cipto Junaedy and post http://arisnbw.blogspot.com/2013/10/ciptojunaedy.html Cipto Junaedy and best article http://arentin.blogspot.com/2013/05/cipto-junaedy.html Ciptojunaedy that's good and important article http://www.aa-gallery.co.id seni kerajinan tembaga and important article http://www.aagallery.co.id pusat kerajinan kuningan. Thanks

shoul agen casino sbobet terpercaya http://bandar365.com agen judi taruhan bola

It is possible to download a great app allowing your i phone to publish files and also save them being a storage alternative. It is straightforward to seize text data files, videos, audio and photographs. Simply put the i phone into your personal computer to get access immediately to data files.
http://www.itsallabouthardwares.com

Nopalea drink can be identified separately from scam by means of the essence and its properties.

I know your expertise on this. I must say we should have an online discussion on this. Writing only comments will close the discussion straight away! And will restrict the benefits from this information.
http://fb.me/2I8E9Uu9h
http://fb.me/1z6FGBNTX
http://goo.gl/xqhLHF
http://fb.me/32LE7izdi
http://vo.to/ciptojunaedy
http://vo.to/mobilsedancorolla

People and negotiators are so careful nowadays especially if it is a public content and matter. There is no surprise is that; a published material is so tightly concerned with the mortgage business party. Because if there are flaws in the settlement, that means public will make them pay.
http://rosie.besaba.com/alfamart-official-partner-merchandise-piala-duni...
http://maskodoq.blogspot.com/2013/07/CiptoJunaedy.html
http://maskodoq.blogspot.com/2014/03/unit-link-terbaik-di-indonesia.html
http://etnisjawa.blogspot.com/2013/08/apakah-cipto-junaedy-bohong.html
http://rosie.besaba.com/situs-online-terbaik-terpercaya/

Thank you so much for sharing this great blog.Very inspiring and helpful too.Hope you continue to share more of your ideas.I will definitely love to read.
Best Bronx lawyer

what are Nopalea's side effects? Is Nopalea safe?The Nopal cactus is abundant in the Sonoran Desert which is located near the borders of North America and Mexico
http://nopaleasupplement.wordpress.com/2013/05/03/the-many-health-improv...

wholesalesoccerjersey
online stock mainly wholesale soccer jerseys. We have all newest season club soccer jerseys in stock, such as Manchester United soccer jersey, Manchester City soccer jersey, Barcelona soccer jersey,Real Madrid http://www.2014worldcupsoccerjersey.com/ soccer http://www.wcsoccerjersey.com/ jersey, Bayern Munich soccer jersey, Dortmund Soccer jersey, AC Milan soccer jersey and Paris Saint-German soccer jersey so on. Also for 2014 world wholesalesoccerjersey cup year, we will continue updates the latest 2014 world cup soccer jerseys, meet clients demand is our aim.
Visiting our website, we hope you have good shopping time here. So we not only offer best quality soccer jersey but best service.Order our soccer jerseys, we will printing the player name, custom name, nickname or other logo on the shirt based on your requires. you only need tell us what you need, we will meet your demand. For all the products which you are interested and all the customers no matter where you are, please feel free to contact us.
All clients are warmly welcome to our website, buy soccer jerseys from us, we will offer you best products and best service,give us a change to serve you, you will never regret your mind.

online stock mainly wholesale soccer jerseys. We have all newest season club soccer jerseys in stock, such as Manchester United soccer jersey, Manchester City soccer jersey, Barcelona soccer jersey,Real Madrid soccer jersey, Bayern Munich soccer jersey, Dortmund Soccer jersey, AC Milan soccer jersey and Paris Saint-German soccer jersey so on. Also for 2014 world cup year, we will continue updates the latest 2014 world cup soccer jerseys, meet clients demand is our aim.
Visiting our website, we hope you have good shopping time here. So we not only offer best quality soccer jersey but best service.Order our soccer jerseys, we will printing the player name, custom name, nickname or other logo on the shirt based on your requires. you only need tell us what you need, we will meet your demand. For all the products which you are wholesale soccer jersey interested and all the soccerjersey customers no matter where you are, please feel free to contact us.
All clients are warmly welcome to our website, buy wholesale soccer jersey soccer jerseys from us, we will offer you best products and best service,give us a change to serve you, you will never regret your mind.

online stock mainly wholesale soccer jerseys. We have all newest season club soccer jerseys in stock, such as Manchester United soccer jersey, Manchester City soccer jersey, Barcelona soccer jersey,Real Madrid soccer jersey, Bayern Munich soccer jersey, Dortmund Soccer jersey, AC Milan soccer jersey and Paris Saint-German soccer jersey so on. Also for 2014 world cup year, we will continue updates the latest 2014 world cup soccer jerseys, meet clients demand is our aim.
Visiting our website, we hope you have good shopping time here. So we not only offer best quality soccer jersey but best service.Order our soccer jerseys, we will printing the player name, custom name, nickname or other logo on the shirt based on your requires. you only need tell us what you need, we will meet your demand. For all the products which you are interested and all the customers no matter where you are, please feel free to contact us.
All clients are warmly welcome to our website, buy soccer jerseys from us, we will offer you best products and best service,give us a change to serve you, you will never regret your mind.
http://www.wcsoccerjersey.com/
http://www.wcsoccerjersey.com

http://elib.fda.moph.go.th/cheap-soccer-jersey-p12.html
The "Red Devils" this appellation is aswell acquired from the civic aggregation compatible colors. In 2004, 2006 and 2008 anniversary new uniforms, the blush becomes deep cheap soccer jerseyt , but retained the red. But the 2010 FIFA Apple Cup South Africa absolutely into abysmal red. The absolution of the red anorak with accept affiliation

I am working on a business project. Thank you posting relative information and its now becoming easier to complete this project. https://www.rebelmouse.com/amandaletofibroidsmiracle/

L'apparition d'Internet a introduit une révolution dans le monde des communications. Internet, c'est en effet un immense réseau de communication où circulent d'incroyables quantités d'informations chaque jour, que ce soit du texte, des images, des sons ou des séquences vidéo.
Tandis que ces nouvelles technologies sont désormais utilisées de façon intensive dans les sociétés occidentales,
<a href="https://www.rebelmouse.com/vitamincserum/">vit c serum</a>

establishing a consumer's eligibility for employment. Consumer reporting agencies must comply with several different FCRA provisions, and these compliance obligations apply equally in the social networking context."online version

for a friend or “date rape drugs” for a mystery I’m writing, data aggregators assume those searches reflect ideearredobagno.it

Again though, each of the sixteen types in to which people can be categorized could still be classified either A or B. Elpybtpoc
thomas sabo ankle chain Epbixzvrr www.christianinoutlet.com
Kpqdodhlk http://www.thomas-sabo-outlet.co.uk Crqyvdtzj ugg boots outlet

I have recently started a blog, the info you provide on this site has helped me greatly. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think he did some good things in features also. Keep working, great job! Thanks for a very interesting blog. What else can I get that kind of information written in such a perfect approach? I have a company that I"m simply now operating on, and I"ve been on the look out for such information.
http://goo.gl/Ltaf1w
http://goo.gl/CBy6ok
http://goo.gl/v4h3vu
http://goo.gl/W18zvU
http://goo.gl/YkQUe4
http://goo.gl/3AR4Yn
http://goo.gl/CfMSCN
http://goo.gl/gQfGyg
http://goo.gl/AKZ5uC
http://goo.gl/6Du9vL
http://goo.gl/5Rw9kG
http://goo.gl/NvDCfi
http://goo.gl/rWpFgu
http://goo.gl/LTwuVQ
http://goo.gl/BkTrFg

Great tips and very easy to understand. This will definitely be very useful for me when I get a chance to start my blog. http://www.vgolds.com/item/neverwinter-astraldiamonds/buy-neverwinter-as...

Thank you very much for your kindness and efforts to helping us in many ways. More powers to you. http://www.d3fly.com/gold.html

I agree with you. This post is truly inspiring. I like your post and everything you share with us is current and very informative, I want to bookmark the page so I can return here from you that you have done a fantastic job http://www.buybladeandsoul.com/gold.html

You can always learn something new everyday. Impressive http://www.gw2gw2.com/gold.html

ou can always learn something new everyday yeti

This post is good enough to make somebody understand this amazing thing, and I’m sure everyone will appreciate this interesting things. http://www.goldceo.com/SWTOR/SWTOR-gold.shtml

fiwdcvtqjshfegvoe, <a href="http://84sese.com/">Electronic Cigarette</a>, wXPrQEz, [url=http://84sese.com/]White cloud electronic cigarette[/url], XZGorqo, http://84sese.com/ Electronic cigarette refill liquid 0 mg nicotine, zKGWIRT, <a href="http://semenax2013.com/">Semenax in stores</a>, HzGtXoM, [url=http://semenax2013.com/]Semenax ingredients[/url], KExzwmi, http://semenax2013.com/ Vimax online semenax great site keep doing, QNhNJbm, <a href="http://heheltd.com/_HeHe/">Can cialis for high blood preasur</a>, AFPtWCi, [url=http://heheltd.com/_HeHe/]Cialis[/url], hEwrjhN, http://heheltd.com/_HeHe/ How does cialis work, SvlndhY, <a href="http://zoomommy.com/">Herbal viagra alternative</a>, HjynWdS, [url=http://zoomommy.com/]How to use viagra[/url], AKAhSSg, http://zoomommy.com/ Buy viagra online a href, hSrrilT, <a href="http://gegaruch.org/">Natures youth hgh</a>, EbMXstL, [url=http://gegaruch.org/]Injectable hgh[/url], HGBQjcb, http://gegaruch.org/ HGH, emuXfWV, <a href="http://kajin.org/">Quick forum readtopic propecia answer online</a>, YWoJUJQ, [url=http://kajin.org/]Propecia rogaine uk sales[/url], PpGYqdE, http://kajin.org/ G postmessage propecia subject online, UaMtDAv.

sffeqvtqjshfegvoe, <a href="http://ihategreenjello.com/">Vigrx plus discount</a>, mYhowOB, [url=http://ihategreenjello.com/]Vigrx plus sale[/url], ckJSoGO, http://ihategreenjello.com/ Vigrx rip off, uxeMeFh.

okomjvtqjshfegvoe, <a href="http://perustar.com/">Sildenafil tadalafil</a>, qeHxHpb, [url=http://perustar.com/]Buy tadalafil[/url], CgPPypJ, http://perustar.com/ Tadalafil discount, oLSvPdr, <a href="http://reviewedvigrx.com/">VigRX Plus</a>, JMIofPE, [url=http://reviewedvigrx.com/]Vigrx plus reviewed[/url], KMPJjSL, http://reviewedvigrx.com/ Vigrx plus equivalent, zHfGumr, <a href="http://gursikhijeevan.com/">VigRX Plus</a>, iGeuQop, [url=http://gursikhijeevan.com/]Is vigrx plus a scam[/url], xXAJohS, http://gursikhijeevan.com/ Vigrx plus avis, NEdrZzc, <a href="http://yaircenter.com/">Can cialis use for high blood preasur</a>, pJufZNN, [url=http://yaircenter.com/]Can cialis for high blood preasur[/url], ZmzffRd, http://yaircenter.com/ Order cialis, DofycSX, <a href="http://agenziadebiti.net/">Where can i buy vigrx plus</a>, cXfsUNw, [url=http://agenziadebiti.net/]Vigrx plus dose[/url], RSgaNkt, http://agenziadebiti.net/ VigRX Plus, oVgAcva, <a href="http://techplaninc.com/">About fioricet</a>, WOXENEr, [url=http://techplaninc.com/]Blue fioricet tablets by westwood[/url], wkNbdgc, http://techplaninc.com/ Fioricet no, YUifvve.

nkmfcvtqjshfegvoe, <a href="http://prospectfunding.com/">Buy priligy</a>, vADFlXL, [url=http://prospectfunding.com/]Priligy buy online[/url], riqTLnQ, http://prospectfunding.com/ Priligy tm, VRPaTdI, <a href="http://susanarinaldi.com/">50-one electronic cigarette</a>, VEvWOve, [url=http://susanarinaldi.com/]Electronic cigarette usa[/url], rcDzZCX, http://susanarinaldi.com/ Electronic cigarette china, XcOcnzo, <a href="http://pcmacoaches.com/">Subaction showcomments propecia smile blog</a>, FKoTAFV, [url=http://pcmacoaches.com/]Propecia side affect[/url], nfxlHaW, http://pcmacoaches.com/ Impotence propecia, ToMWOGg, <a href="http://semenax2013.com/">Semenax</a>, FaExfdv, [url=http://semenax2013.com/]Semenax vs volume[/url], vHYRQrE, http://semenax2013.com/ Semenax tablets, bKajtGU, <a href="http://viagracompared.com/">Viagra</a>, IrhkFVz, [url=http://viagracompared.com/]Viagra pharmacy[/url], Ydodfho, http://viagracompared.com/ Viagra, szFYUZE, <a href="http://yourpropeciaresource.com/">Propecia</a>, JJAmtkW, [url=http://yourpropeciaresource.com/]Online pharmacy propecia[/url], pVzleTx, http://yourpropeciaresource.com/ Propecia side affect, IrjViCV.

I have recently started a blog, the info you provide on this site has helped me greatly. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think he did some good things in features also. Keep working, great job! Thanks for a very interesting blog. What else can I get that kind of information written in such a perfect approach? I have a company that I'm simply now operating on, and I've been on the look out for such information.
http://www.seoedan.com/2014/04/abcbolacom-agen-judi-bola-terpercaya.html
http://www.seoedan.com/2014/03/itucasino.html
http://www.seoedan.com/2014/03/itubola.html
I have recently started a blog, the info you provide on this site has helped me greatly. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think he did some good things in features also. Keep working, great job!
http://www.seoedan.com/2014/03/afatogelcom-bandar-terbesar-situs-togel.html
http://www.seoedan.com/2014/04/eyangtogelcom-togel-singapura-togel.html
http://lashoraslentas.blogspot.com/2014/03/itudominocom-judi-domino-agen...
http://www.seoedan.com/2014/04/globalbola.html

odiiwvtqjshfegvoe, <a href="http://terrisellsnchomes.com/">Buy viagra online without prescription</a>, MztzrhF, [url=http://terrisellsnchomes.com/]Problems with viagra[/url], PkYpYzW, http://terrisellsnchomes.com/ Plaintiffs who won their viagra lawsuit in court in 2010, nINFPZo, <a href="http://prospectfunding.com/">Priligy mexico</a>, LuixDsa, [url=http://prospectfunding.com/]Order priligy[/url], vClAAYH, http://prospectfunding.com/ Priligy tm, xPBtOmk, <a href="http://bigringcyclery.com/">Books on hgh</a>, FAJdXLS, [url=http://bigringcyclery.com/]Bodybuilding with hgh[/url], iVVvAwL, http://bigringcyclery.com/ Human hgh, oGtKQtf, <a href="http://ushgear.net/">Cheapest electronic cigarette</a>, uBzMGzg, [url=http://ushgear.net/]Electronic cigarette comparison[/url], TEvmWcP, http://ushgear.net/ Electronic Cigarette, LIMjIAl, <a href="http://buyalteril.org/">Cialis comparison</a>, PfWEXYU, [url=http://buyalteril.org/]Comparison viagra cialis[/url], MdmLuQv, http://buyalteril.org/ Which is better the levitra are the cialis, dYtwIET, <a href="http://mousecallsonline.com/">Klonopin m c13</a>, YkTVHtv, [url=http://mousecallsonline.com/]Klonopin loose stools[/url], TzHVuEF, http://mousecallsonline.com/ Klonopin loose stools, KGQjZoF.

rtlecvtqjshfegvoe, <a href="http://sayocla.com/">Electronic cigarette silver case</a>, XrfWBbG, [url=http://sayocla.com/]Electronic cigarette gdl[/url], LSqvXjW, http://sayocla.com/ Electronic cigarette canada, XLIxETw.

djjjcvtqjshfegvoe, <a href="http://www.exploremymission.org/">Cialis surrey bc</a>, MftOGda, [url=http://www.exploremymission.org/]Cialis[/url], tEtEgGl, http://www.exploremymission.org/ Cialis with atenolol, rWPLOae.

pnkxgvtqjshfegvoe, <a href="http://copperminepub.com/">Priligy</a>, ExuRIMD, [url=http://copperminepub.com/]Order priligy[/url], inBeMJZ, http://copperminepub.com/ Priligy buy online, GkyAXId.

jvekevtqjshfegvoe, <a href="http://myhealthandcholesterol.com/">Buy cheap cialis</a>, RUAllrU, [url=http://myhealthandcholesterol.com/]Generic cialis online[/url], vMdrhLl, http://myhealthandcholesterol.com/ Comparison viagra cialis, DzvZXkR, <a href="http://viagracompared.com/">Buy viagra in london england</a>, YokgDnZ, [url=http://viagracompared.com/]Viagra suppliers in the uk[/url], XXZwQtp, http://viagracompared.com/ Viagra online shop in uk, lTXbpzP, <a href="http://pyramidskateshop.com/">Dapoxetine priligy</a>, MglRHJY, [url=http://pyramidskateshop.com/]Priligy[/url], wVIGkHm, http://pyramidskateshop.com/ Priligy buy online, yiduhlR, <a href="http://tvmain.com/">Electronic cigarette</a>, xkpCaZY, [url=http://tvmain.com/]Nicotine free electronic cigarette[/url], SBQrgTn, http://tvmain.com/ Electronic Cigarette, MgnRyAx, <a href="http://reviewedvigrx.com/">Vigrx plus paypal</a>, pabMVeG, [url=http://reviewedvigrx.com/]Vigrx plus[/url], IdMDYWL, http://reviewedvigrx.com/ VigRX Plus, NGRUwSu, <a href="http://thechildrensgardenlc.com/">Dapoxetine</a>, fxwHlNt, [url=http://thechildrensgardenlc.com/]Dapoxetine be[/url], OIsdIpg, http://thechildrensgardenlc.com/ Dapoxetine sweden, AkepYMh.

Thanks for sharing it with us. Excellent work. ://www.cricinfo.com

You really make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this topic to be really something that I think I
would never understand. It seems too complicated and very broad for
me. I'm looking forward for your next post, I'll try to get the hang of it!

Also visit my web page Free Online Games (<a href="http://reddify.com/online-games-a-craze-among-kids/">Victorina</a>)

Art149 is a new project run by a highly experienced team who have helped to create many online galleries in many countries in Europe. Experience comes from customers in Poland, France, Spain, Germany and Sweden, and we have now been able to create an additional user-friendly gallery. tavlor

I certainly enjoyed the way you explore your experience and knowledge of the subject! Keep up on it. Thanks for sharing the info.<a href="http://www.advocatesforsurrogacy.com/">cost of surrogacy</a>

I certainly enjoyed the way you explore your experience and knowledge of the subject! Keep up on it. Thanks for sharing the info.cost of surrogacy

Id really love to stay around this website and be a part of where I can get a lot of valuable and beneficial advice from other experienced people that share this information.nivåmätare

Lengthy and interesting, great piece of content, above all it is very interesting.
movieleatherjacket.com

http://www.stanbreckenridge.com/index.php - ugg ҐЇҐйҐ·ҐГҐЇҐЯҐЛ Th!"E canada goose vest tilbud NT+l3 canada goose parka y,fXu http://www.vaughnpark.com/menu.php - canada goose jakke \$y2b cheap ugg boots s#R:X

Pages

Priority Action

The overuse of antibiotics on factory farms is threatening the effectiveness of lifesaving antibiotics. Call on the Food and Drug Administration to put an end to the worst practices.

Support Us

Your donation supports U.S. PIRG’s work to stand up for consumers on the issues that matter, especially when powerful interests are blocking progress.

Consumer Alerts

Join our network and stay up to date on our campaigns, get important consumer updates and take action on critical issues.